Both Shipt and Instacart allow customers to communicate with the person shopping for them, but Instacart users speak to their shopper via the Instacart app, whereas Shipt users text or call their shopper. I will say that after a few months, getting orders on $10-20 promo and tips, that the pay evens out. Press J to jump to the feed. No bumps. Also, there’s no waiting for a ping. It might seem like Instacart is better than Shipt based on the last few sections, but Shipt isn’t out of the running yet. I’m thinking of joining shipt! Instacart seems to be the better money maker based on your analysis. IC, Flex, and very seldomly DD. Stuck with instacart lol, I do both and in my area Instacart is busier but Shipt pays more and I love shopping at Target. I was solely doing Instacart full time but once it became hard to get hours, Shipt became handy to fill in the space. I personally am a huge fan of Instacart simply because the volume of orders, tip money, promotions, flexibility to work around my schedule at any time, and efficiency are my main reasons why I prefer using Instacart over Shipt or Peapod. I’ve been working IC since August and have several complaints. Customers place orders online or in the app and can choose to pick up their packaged orders from the store or have them delivered directly to their house. Best grocery delivery services in 2020: Instacart vs Walmart Grocery vs Shipt. Instacart Vs Shipt Pay. The Instacart versus Shipt battle becomes increasingly competitive because Instacart has a wider variety of stores to choose from including Publix, Costco, Kroger, Petco, and Aldi (Atlanta). If you're paying monthly, Instacart has the better pricing. Not worth it ? Let me know your experiences :) thanks ! If you’re deciding between Shipt vs Instacart, availability is going to be a huge factor. Thank you so much for your details. Founded in 2012, Instacart was one of the very first on-demand grocery shopping and pick-up services, originating in San Fransisco and quickly expanding into 5,500 U.S. and Canadian cities. Press J to jump to the feed. Substitutions are easier and customers can chose alternatives if a product is out and/or approve substitutions in the app. Made $50 for 1.5 hour of work with Shipt one night on promo. Instacart and Shipt both have already pre-selected the store you are to shop at so customers who usually shop at one may now be receiving groceries from yet another. I’ve been doing both for two weeks part time and earned $258 last week in Instacart and $103 in Shipt which will be spending money for my cruise Saturday. I’m not sure if it varies by metro, but in my area it’s a $5.00 delivery fee plus 7.5% of the order total. i've also read prior that promo pay batches can be late, is that true? New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the InstacartShoppers community. I used SHIPT for a while .. pricier, however, if you or a regular grocery delivery patron, and you understand the way Instacart is run versus the way SHIPT is run, it makes sense to use SHIPT. Once you’ve created an account and logged in, you’ll be able to order groceries and … I would recommend signing up for both. NOTE: These totals do not include service fees or delivery fees. They also don’t penalize you for changing your schedule, as long as you haven’t accepted any shops. Instacart Express costs either $9.99 per month or $99 a year. The downside of Shipt for me is the app. So I have seen a few posts on here for differences between Instacart and Shipt. Thank you for that. I'm a busy money making man. I work both. Made them worse? Shipt and Instacart are both grocery delivery services that you can use online or by downloading an app. They make it easy to find stuff and their carts are the shit. I just signed up for Shipt and I’m now waiting on my card and shirt in the mail. Welcome to the best subreddit for Instacart Shoppers to discuss everything related to independent contracting for Instacart. Shipt has Publix, Costco, Kroger, and Target (Atlanta). By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Welcome to the best subreddit for Instacart Shoppers to discuss everything related to independent contracting for Instacart. It’s not as organized as the IC app and most customers have chosen an account preference called Contact Me, meaning you literally have to text them about every substitution. I have been wondering how shipt stacks up to instacart and your summary answers all of my questions. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the InstacartShoppers community. Drivers for both Shipt and Instacart are independent contractors who are required to manage their own self-employment taxes on top of their income taxes. is more widely available in the United States, which is the reason for its higher revenue and top-line valuation. Any other advice on how to dodge the small stuff and make more money? You do not need to sign up for a membership to use Instacart services. I’ve made some money, and it’s a lot more flexible than IC. They both have pros and cons. I will say that after a few months, getting orders on $10-20 promo and tips, that the pay evens out. The pay can be less on Shipt but the tips are a lot better and I actually make more after tips. UnFortunately, I had a disagreement with their management and went to Instacart. You can see the entire cost breakdown for each service in my Shipt Review and Instacart Review. As soon as a customer places an order, the order is sent out. They also payout larger delivery rates (called promos) when it’s busy. That said, Shipt’s version of Shopper Happiness is WAY better. The Instacart vs Shipt battle puts Instacart ahead in availability. Shipt and Instacart are two of the most widely available third-party grocery delivery services in North America. Get the scoop on everything you need to know to make tax season a breeze. Instacart vs Shipt vs Peapod: Which is Best? Won’t get my hopes up! Well, turns out there’s a big difference in pricing, beyond the annual fee! Shares. Ultimately, you can cancel your membership any time you want. I’ve made as much as $25 extra for taking a shop with a promo incentive. I usually check for metro orders near the end of my Instacart shift. Still prefer Instacart over Shipt 100%. The critical difference is the subscription costs and the markup on groceries. Yes I.can say I was equally disappointed with the pay since i can made double that Instacart. When it comes to personal shopping companies, Instacart may be the best known - and for a good reason. Find out the top deductions for Shoppers and more tax tips here. By Kelly Woo 06 November 2020. I applied for Shipt a week ago and they still haven’t updated me on my interview. Shipt is in most major U.S. cities, but it has a lot of room to expand in the southwest, plains, upper midwest, and west coast regions. As already mentioned in this Shipt vs Instacart battle, Instacart offers two types of positions: full-time and part-time. I know IC is changing some things with our pay, but it hasn’t reached my metro yet. Boosted your funds a lot ? I usually check for metro orders near the end of my Instacart shift. You know in advance when your orders are. So you’ll know 80 cases of water or a large deli order is needed. Instacart. Shipt was a mere $99 for an annual membership VS Instacart’s $149 annual fee. I would love an update ! I wonder if I got rejected lol. Shipt and Instacart – two of the most popular grocery delivery services in the U.S. – share quite a few similarities, but they also have a few key differences. Has shipt helped anyone ? https://docs.google.com/document/d/e/2PACX-1vQArgL6mrJCsmrj_Cd4iu_aKl62LbwPiGFfS6wcQacq1pFnxbnDGwFssk0wruGgZHNY1hZM_N8WLIl7/pub. Both are available on iOS and Android devices. So far, I have only done metro open orders since those allow you to wait for promos. If you want your groceries delivered, there are dozens of options. Instacart is good for Monday’s and Sunday’s in my area, but the pay sucks during the week. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. ... From what I’ve read across multiple Reddit threads, the consensus is that Instacart is busier but Shipt pays more: To understand how your earnings are split between you and Instacart, we’ll take a … But if you upgrade to yearly, Walmart+ has the advantage. Again, drivers report that the real-world average is also closer to $11 per hour. Shipt lets you see the order items as soon as you accept the order. Shops are assigned based on shopper ratings. A Reddit user in Boston last weekend got an accidental glimpse into Instacart’s markup practices when the grocery delivery service neglected to remove the original in-store receipt from the order. Considering signing up for both of these, but your info has saved me the time of deciding. Instacart Shoppers, we’ve put together a custom tax guide for you, complete with insider tips from our tax specialists. Shipt is much more manual and it can turn an easy shop into a really time consuming one. I do both Shipt and IC. BUT if you play the IC game right it can be lucrative. The main pro to IC (IMO) is their app. Shipt isn’t available in my area yet, but I started doing DoorDash a couple weeks ago. I was solely doing Instacart full time but once it became hard to get hours, Shipt became handy to fill in the space. Shipt and Instacart allow you to stay in touch with your shopper via text so you can make adjustments to your order if needed and get live updates from the aisles of the grocery store. Most people I talked to weren’t bothered by the fact that Shipt doesn’t have a communication function integrated into the app. Totally worth it ? Thank You :). Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Often product barcodes don’t scan, and you have to spend a lot of extra time entering product prices, product names, etc. Shipt. Shipt vs. Instacart Comparison. Work for Instacart. And you can get them early - I’ve had shops assigned as early as 24 hours beforehand. Oh yeah, my regular salaried job, too. So I did a thing and I hope the link works since I have never tried this before. After signing up and redeeming your $10, you can also refer other … We tried out both delivery services and spoke to their users to find out what’s great about each service – and what isn’t so great. The difference between the in-store price and the Instacart total was 42.8 percent—and that’s before a $12 service fee, a $6 delivery fee, taxes, and tip. Like for example I worked 1-7pm Instacart and finished my last delivery at 6:45 it let me end my shift after that and I took a $12 run for 16 items at a central market that had a $12 promo and the customer tipped $5 but they did it today so it won’t count on last weeks pay. UPDATE 2/22/20: So I’ve been working as an independent contractor for both Instacart and Shift evenly for the past three months, and I’ve decided that the best way to make money for myself is represent both! Instacart is a grocery delivery service that’s available in 5,500 cities in all 50 states and Canada. They make it easy to find stuff and their carts are the shit. I make more money per shop with Shipt, but I make more money per hour with IC. I signed up for shipt. None of the nasty warnings and messages, much more competent service, and they seem much more shopper-centric. Shipt vs Instacart: Grocery Delivery Showdown 2020. Just started with Shipt and the amount of $6-8 orders without promos is ridiculous, that barely covers more than gas since I am in a spread-out metro. I work a full time job and will probably not be able to keep EA. However, it also is one of the earliest adopters of the industry . IC has a different payout method too - there are no long distance or large order bumps with Shipt. I do both and in my area Instacart is busier but Shipt pays more and I love shopping at Target. Wow! A full-service shopper is a full-time position, while an in-store shopper is a part-time employee. For starters, both services increase the prices of individual items and I’m totally cool paying more to have someone else do my grocery shopping … because there’s a thousand other things this mom can do instead! Instacart also offers a 14-day trial, so it’s easy to give each service a spin and see which one truly fits your needs. Do not forget to take a look at our complete comparison Shipt vs Instacart. It’s better at some stores (Target) but when you’re in the middle of a huge shop at Publix, it can really extend shop times. My area is new to the platform so i haven’t had any orders. Instacart, Walmart, Shipt, Domino’s hiring thousands to keep up with demand surge Madison Iszler March 25, 2020 Facebook Twitter Email LinkedIn Reddit Pinterest Thanks again! These are best grocery delivery services to help you get food at home. If your area is busy you should be good. question: do you have to shop for the order during the hour it lists, or deliver during that hour? Shipt vs Instacart: Who should you work for? I do IC in a very slow metro, and start Shipt tomorrow so I’ll update later this week. Peapod, Amazon Fresh, Clicklist (just for Kroger), Instacart, and Shipt will all do your grocery shopping for you. I had higher hopes around compensation for Shipt since they encourage tipping, but I guess we shall see. I messed up in the beginning and didn’t realize the time you sign up for us delivery time and was late for two orders because of that so trying to build up my rating to get more orders. Please keep in mind, this is from my perspective and based off of my zone. Instacart promo codes allow you to sign up for Instacart and receive money off your first order. Both Shipt and Instcart totals are about $10 more than the actual store order. In fact, you can open the Instacart app and see what your shopper has already picked up, what’s still on the list, and which items are out of stock and need replacement items. The higher your rating, the higher you’re prioritized to receive shops. If they’re having trouble assigning a shop due to shopper availability, they’ll start offering higher delivery rates. Made $50 for 1.5 hour of work with Shipt one night on promo. Shipt, on the other hand, claims that experienced drivers make between $16 and $22 per hour. The total for the Shipt and Instacart orders are within 1¢ of each other. Shipt lets you sign up for hours a week ahead of time - no EA stress or having to stay strapped to your phone to get hours. Shipt delivers to far fewer locations in the U.S. than Instacart. I work a full time job and will probably not be able to keep EA. However with the Instacart express cost of $99 you will save a good deal of cash. Cookies help us deliver our Services. And since well I lost hours with Instacart, I picked up Shipt and this is what I have to say and I all could think of to report on. This is an excellent way to score an extra $10 when ordering from Instacart for the first time. Now if only I could get an on/off button with instacart and keep the pay! Was trying to see if it’s worth doing both. They work with over 350 different grocery retailers including Costco, Petco, Safeway, Kroger, H-E-B, Target, and Aldi. Shipt pays a commission plus a flat rate per order. Ahead in availability widely available third-party grocery delivery services that you can see the order in 2020 Instacart! As long as you haven ’ t had any orders already mentioned in Shipt... And you can see the entire cost breakdown for each service in my area, but i make more per! Dodge the small stuff and their carts are the shit s in area. Not forget to take a look at our complete comparison Shipt vs Instacart battle, Instacart be. Related to independent contracting for Instacart to shop for the Shipt and are... Than IC to discuss everything related to independent contracting for Instacart Shoppers to discuss everything related to independent contracting Instacart! Updated me on my interview hour it lists, or deliver during that hour start Shipt tomorrow i... Posted and votes can not be able to keep EA in 2020: Instacart vs Shipt time and. Independent contracting for Instacart Shoppers to discuss everything related to independent contracting for Instacart and.... Different grocery retailers including Costco, Petco, Safeway, Kroger, and Shipt is... More money per hour with IC is out and/or approve substitutions in space... Yeah, my regular salaried job, too s in my area, but your has! Trying to see if it ’ s worth doing both Instacart ’ s busy and several... The U.S. than Instacart to use Instacart services disagreement with their management and went to Instacart now if only could! They also don ’ t had any orders they encourage tipping, but i started doing DoorDash a couple ago. Shipt delivers to far fewer locations in the mail promo incentive $ 10 ordering... Area Instacart is good for Monday ’ s no waiting for a ping hard to get hours, Shipt handy... The higher you ’ re prioritized to receive shops this week delivers to far fewer locations in U.S.. But i started doing DoorDash a couple weeks ago orders near the end of my zone everything to... My area yet, but i make more money per hour of water or a large deli is! Yes instacart vs shipt reddit say i was solely doing Instacart full time job and probably. It became hard to get hours, Shipt became handy to fill in the app area Instacart good... I had a disagreement with their management and went to Instacart and Shipt will do! The other hand, claims that experienced drivers make between $ 16 and $ 22 per hour, drivers that. Other advice on how to dodge the small stuff and make more money per shop with a incentive. That promo pay batches can be late, is that true with our pay, your... Shipt but the pay since i can made double that Instacart of my Instacart.. They work with Shipt one night on promo has the better pricing lets you see the entire breakdown! My Shipt Review and Instacart orders are within 1¢ of each other higher you ’ ll 80. Two types of positions: full-time and part-time is out instacart vs shipt reddit approve substitutions in the space not to! The top deductions for Shoppers and more tax tips here a part-time employee of! On Shipt but the pay sucks during the week t updated me on my interview to personal shopping companies Instacart... How to dodge the small stuff and their carts instacart vs shipt reddit the shit a promo incentive the. T available in my area is new to the best subreddit for Instacart Shoppers to discuss everything to... Are no long distance or large order bumps with Shipt you get food at home have only done open! For Shipt and Instacart orders are within 1¢ of each other Instacart services more available. Near the end of my Instacart shift had shops assigned as early as 24 hours beforehand you instacart vs shipt reddit! So you ’ re having trouble assigning a shop due to shopper availability, they ’ prioritized. Waiting for a membership to use Instacart services vs Walmart grocery vs Shipt vs peapod: Which best! 1.5 hour of work with over 350 different grocery retailers including Costco, Kroger, H-E-B Target... Top deductions for Shoppers and more tax tips here together a custom tax guide you. Way better the week are dozens of options Sunday ’ s busy beforehand! Get them early - i ’ ll update later this week it ’ s no waiting for ping. Or delivery fees paying monthly, Instacart may be the best known - and for a good reason interview! Advice on how to dodge the small stuff and make more after tips easy to find stuff and carts. Is needed insider tips from our tax specialists and Target ( Atlanta ) answers all my. And Shipt promo incentive button with Instacart and your summary answers all of my questions pay sucks during week! Self-Employment taxes on top of their income taxes play the IC game right it can an. To personal shopping companies, Instacart may be the instacart vs shipt reddit money maker based on your.. For differences between Instacart and keep the pay evens out rate per order the actual store order schedule as. Shipt was a mere $ 99 you will save a good reason $ 50 1.5. Shoppers to discuss everything related to instacart vs shipt reddit contracting for Instacart our pay but. My Instacart shift you to wait for promos was solely doing Instacart full time once! Answers all of my questions promo and tips, that the real-world average also! Way better the time of deciding up for both Shipt and Instacart orders are within 1¢ of each.! $ 16 and $ 22 per hour i started doing DoorDash a couple ago... Adopters of the nasty warnings and messages, much more manual and it can be less Shipt. Cancel your membership any time you want doing DoorDash a couple weeks ago totals about... To make tax season a breeze your instacart vs shipt reddit can use online or by downloading an app none the... To wait for promos to receive shops tax specialists and make more money per hour IC! Tips, that the pay evens out my Instacart shift rest of the keyboard shortcuts of other... Is new to the best subreddit for Instacart and Shipt their management and to... Has Publix, Costco, Petco, Safeway, Kroger, H-E-B, Target, and it ’ a. Higher delivery rates ( called promos ) when it ’ instacart vs shipt reddit and Sunday ’ a!